The Supreme Court: Guardian of the Constitution
Introduction
The Supreme Court stands at the apex of a nation's judiciary, acting as the ultimate interpreter of the constitution, protector of civil rights, and final arbiter of justice. In democracies across the world, and notably in the United States and India, the Supreme Court plays a vital role in shaping law and society through its landmark rulings. This article explores the historical foundation, structure, functioning, powers, and landmark cases of the Supreme Court, highlighting its essential role in upholding democratic values.
History and Evolution of the Supreme Court
The idea of a supreme judicial authority traces back to ancient legal systems, but the modern concept of the Supreme Court evolved during the Enlightenment and matured within constitutional democracies like the United States and India.
The United States Supreme Court
Established under Article III of the U.S. Constitution in 1789, the U.S. Supreme Court was created to ensure that federal laws were uniformly interpreted and enforced. It held its first session in 1790, and since then, it has significantly influenced American history.
The Supreme Court of India
The Supreme Court of India, established on January 28, 1950, replaced the Federal Court of India and inherited its judicial authority. Created under the Constitution of India, it was established to ensure justice, equality, and liberty, serving as a check on legislative and executive powers.
Structure and Composition
The structure of the Supreme Court differs from country to country, but typically it includes a Chief Justice and a bench of associate justices or judges. Below is a comparative table of the structure in the United States and India:
| Feature | United States Supreme Court | Supreme Court of India |
|---|---|---|
| Established | 1789 | 1950 |
| Number of Judges (as of 2025) | 9 (1 Chief Justice, 8 Associate) | 34 (1 Chief Justice, 33 Judges) |
| Appointment Process | Nominated by President, confirmed by Senate | Appointed by President, with consultation |
| Retirement Age | Lifetime tenure (subject to impeachment) | 65 years |
| Location | Washington, D.C. | New Delhi |
Jurisdiction and Powers
The Supreme Court exercises original, appellate, and advisory jurisdiction. Its powers extend to constitutional interpretation, judicial review, and enforcement of fundamental rights.
Original Jurisdiction
In both India and the U.S., the Supreme Court has original jurisdiction over disputes involving states, government entities, and constitutional questions.
Appellate Jurisdiction
The Court hears appeals from lower courts, including constitutional, civil, and criminal cases. It reviews decisions made by the High Courts (India) or Circuit/Appellate Courts (U.S.).
Judicial Review
One of the most critical powers of the Supreme Court is judicial review, allowing it to invalidate laws and executive actions that violate the constitution.
Example:
-
Marbury v. Madison (1803) in the U.S. established judicial review.
-
Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala (1973) in India reaffirmed that Parliament cannot alter the "basic structure" of the Constitution.
Role of the Supreme Court in a Democracy
The Supreme Court acts as a watchdog of the Constitution, ensuring all laws and executive actions align with the principles of justice, liberty, and equality. Below are key roles it plays:
1. Interpretation of the Constitution
The Constitution is often a living document that requires interpretation in the context of modern challenges. The Supreme Court ensures laws are read in harmony with constitutional values.
2. Protection of Fundamental Rights
Citizens turn to the Supreme Court when their rights are violated. From freedom of speech to equality before the law, the Court ensures enforcement of these guarantees.
3. Balancing of Powers
In any democracy, maintaining the balance between the legislature, executive, and judiciary is crucial. The Supreme Court often steps in to check overreach.
Landmark Supreme Court Cases
Throughout history, the Supreme Court has delivered verdicts that transformed society. Here are some landmark judgments:
United States
-
Brown v. Board of Education (1954): Ended racial segregation in schools.
-
Roe v. Wade (1973): Recognized a woman's right to abortion (overturned in 2022).
-
Obergefell v. Hodges (2015): Legalized same-sex marriage nationwide.
India
-
Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala (1973): Introduced the “basic structure doctrine”.
-
Shah Bano Case (1985): Strengthened rights of Muslim women to alimony.
-
Navtej Singh Johar v. Union of India (2018): Decriminalized homosexuality.
Challenges Faced by the Supreme Court
Despite its prestige, the Supreme Court is not immune to criticism and challenges:
1. Backlog of Cases
In India, the Supreme Court has a significant backlog with over 70,000 pending cases, affecting timely justice.
2. Political Pressure
Critics argue that the process of appointing judges, especially in the U.S., has become increasingly politicized, potentially undermining judicial independence.
3. Accessibility
The cost and complexity of approaching the Supreme Court often make it inaccessible for marginalized communities.
Recent Developments and Reforms
With changing times, there has been a push for judicial reforms:
Digitization of Proceedings
Both India and the U.S. have moved toward virtual hearings and digital filing systems to improve transparency and access.
Greater Transparency in Appointments
In India, the Collegium System is under scrutiny, with calls for a more transparent method of appointing judges.
Public Outreach
Some courts have taken steps to engage with the public via live-streaming important judgments, enhancing accountability.
The Supreme Court vs Other Courts
Here’s a brief comparison between the Supreme Court and other levels of the judiciary:
| Court Level | Scope | Appeal To | Example Cases |
|---|---|---|---|
| District Courts | Local legal issues, civil/criminal | High Court (India), State Courts (U.S.) | Theft, property disputes |
| High Courts | State-level cases and appeals | Supreme Court | Writ petitions, appeals |
| Supreme Court | National importance, constitutional law | Final authority | Landmark judgments |
Key Functions of the Supreme Court
-
✅ Interprets constitutional provisions
-
✅ Protects fundamental rights
-
✅ Settles disputes between states and union
-
✅ Reviews decisions of lower courts
-
✅ Issues writs (India)
-
✅ Exercises judicial review
-
✅ Advises the executive (India)
Conclusion
The Supreme Court is more than a judicial institution—it is the backbone of democracy. Its ability to interpret the Constitution, safeguard fundamental rights, and check other branches of government ensures that no one is above the law. As societies evolve, so too must the judiciary, with reforms that promote access, transparency, and accountability.
In a world increasingly marked by polarization, misinformation, and rapid change, the Supreme Court remains a stabilizing force—reminding nations of their constitutional promises and delivering justice to those who need it most.
